高级检索

BP人工神经网络与logistic回归模型在石化企业员工蓄积性疲劳预测中比较:基于网络问卷调查

Comparison of back propagation artificial neural network and logistic regression models for predicting cumulative fatigue among petrochemical employees: a web-based questionnaire survey

  • 摘要:
    目的  比较BP人工神经网络(BP-ANN)与logistic回归模型预测石化企业员工蓄积性疲劳风险的效果;评价石化企业员工蓄积性疲劳早期识别、干预的预测模型。
    方法  于2021年7—10月采用整群抽样方法在江苏省某石化企业抽取4 066名员工进行横断面研究。通过网络问卷方式调查员工的一般情况、工作情况、职业紧张状况、蓄积性疲劳患病情况。采用SPSS 23.0软件,通过非参数检验分析石化员工蓄积性疲劳的影响因素。建立BP-ANN和logistic回归两种预测模型并绘制ROC曲线,计算灵敏度、特异性、约登指数和AUC值。比较两者的预测效能。
    结果  共回收有效问卷3 763份。石化企业员工中蓄积性疲劳者占63.2%(2 377/3 763)。综合两种模型分析结果,年龄、周均工作时间、轮班、有职业紧张和规律的体育锻炼是员工蓄积性疲劳的主要影响因素。两种模型的AUC值均>0.7,两种模型在灵敏度(BP 75.7%,logistic 75.6%)方面的表现相近。与logistic回归模型相比,BP-ANN模型在特异性(BP 76.3%,logistic 69.3%)、约登指数(BP 51.9%,logistic 44.9%)和AUC值(BP 84.4%,logistic 79.9%)方面表现更佳。两种模型均可用于预测石化员工蓄积性疲劳发生率,但BP-ANN模型的总体效能优于传统logistic回归模型。
    结论 BP-ANN模型和logistic回归模型可应用于石化企业员工蓄积性疲劳的预测;BP-ANN模型能明显提高预测效能。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective To compare the performance of back propagation artificial neural network (BP-ANN) and logistic regression models in predicting the risk of cumulative fatigue among petrochemical employees and evaluate the prediction models for early identification and intervention of cumulative fatigue in these employees.
    Methods A total of 4 066 employees of a petrochemical enterprise in Jiangsu province were selected by cluster sampling for a cross-sectional study from July to October 2021. A web-based questionnaire was designed to investigate the general information, work conditions, occupational stress, and prevalence of cumulative fatigue among employees. SPSS 23.0 was used to analyze the influencing factors of cumulative fatigue among petrochemical employees through non-parametric tests. BP-ANN and logistic regression models were established and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were plotted to compare the prediction performance of models based on sensitivity, specificity, Youden index, and area under the curve (AUC) value.
    Results A total of 3 763 valid questionnaires were collected, which showed that 63.2% (2 377/3 763) of petrochemical employees experienced cumulative fatigue. The comprehensive analysis of the two models indicated that age, weekly working hours, shift work, occupational stress, and regular exercise were the key factors influencing employees’ cumulative fatigue. Both models had AUC values > 0.7. Sensitivity was comparable between the BP-ANN and logistic models (BP 75.7%, logistic 75.6%). The BP-ANN model achieved higher specificity (BP 76.3%, logistic 69.3%), Youden index (BP 51.9%, logistic 44.9%), and AUC value (BP 84.4%, logistic 79.9%) than the logistic model. Both models can be used to predict the incidence of cumulative fatigue among petrochemical employees, while the overall prediction performance of the BP-ANN model was superior to that of the logistic model.
    Conclusions Both BP-ANN and logistic regression models can be adopted to predict cumulative fatigue among petrochemical employees, with the BP-ANN model showing better prediction performance.

     

/

返回文章
返回